But when these arguments sound convincing, the truth is much less simple.
Sure, the pattern measurement is just too small to attract definitive conclusions however when Buttler has captained from the outfield there was no apparent upturn in outcomes – three wins and 4 defeats his return from seven matches for England and Manchester Originals.
“Being wicketkeeper is a large profit by way of getting tactical info round decision-making,” says Sam Billings, a wicketkeeping captain who has gained the 2021 T20 Blast and the previous two editions of the Hundred as skipper.
“As a wicketkeeper you’ll be able to learn circumstances, subject positions, and the angles much better than every other place on the sphere.”
There have been few extra profitable white-ball captains than India’s 2011 World Cup-winning skipper MS Dhoni, famed for his tweaks and tactical nous from behind the stumps.
“It’s laborious to go from captaining and holding your entire profession to vary to a captain at additional cowl the entire time,” Billings provides.
“[Former England skipper] Eoin Morgan was such a great captain as a result of he had at all times captained from cowl and labored on these conversations.”
There’s additionally, after all, no assure that fewer tasks means an upturn in outcomes.
McCullum’s profession might effectively have been prolonged by giving up the gloves however his batting common was simply 29.76 after doing so.
Ought to he need to keep on as keeper, Buttler might simply level to considered one of his different confidantes, Kumar Sangakkara.
The Sri Lanka nice saved wicket till the tip and completed his illustrious ODI profession with 4 centuries in his final 5 matches.
The stats might effectively inform Buttler no matter it’s he desires to listen to.